Physical Game Magazines You Should Subscribe To

Growing up in the 90s, there was nothing quite like getting a new Nintendo Power in the mail. The bulk of my gaming news came solely from the sweet, sweet pages of the magazine. So did strategy and tips for beating games! I would always rollerblade around our neighborhood mailbox (ah, the 90s) on the day I knew it would come because I was so excited. And even though Nintendo Power was my jam, I used frequently pick up GamePro and Electronic Gaming Monthly too. I’d just tear through the pages, soaking up every last bit of gaming goodness. If you’re as nostalgic as I am for these times, then you’re in luck! Here are five amazing physical game magazines you should subscribe to today.

Mario Golf N64 box and cart, and Switch Player Issue 53 (Mario Golf)

Nintendo Force

The spiritual successor to Nintendo Power! It debuted in January 2013 just after Nintendo Power’s final issue, and was even staffed by some former NP editors. This bi-monthly labor of love is probably my current favorite magazine to read! The editors are all insightful and witty, the magazine is gorgeously laid out and well organized, and each issue’s “key feature” is a clever nostalgic trip. There’s big release reviews, indie spotlights, “collector’s corners”, a new book club, and fun comics. If you have kids, you’ll often see perspectives on which games are great to play with them, which I appreciate. There’s really something for everyone! And each issue also comes with a double sided poster, which is another awesome throwback to Nintendo Power. I enjoy the mag so much that I actually did a full post about the glory that is Nintendo Force. Check it out-it’s definitely a physical game magazine you should subscribe to, and they have several subscription tiers!

Collage of Nintendo Force magazine covers
Some of my favorite NF covers!

Ninty Fresh

July 2023 update: Unfortunately, Ninty Fresh is being discontinued and merged with a soon-to-be-announced new venture from the staff. I’m keeping (most) of the original post for posterity!

As of mid-2023, there have been eight (glorious) issues of the UK-based Ninty Fresh. Each issue is a sort of “anthology” for a specific Nintendo series, but also has other retrospectives (like one for the Virtual Boy in the Zelda issue-love it!) as well as current news and reviews. Thus far, there have been delightful issues for Mario, F-Zero, Pokemon, Zelda (my favorite series of all time), Metroid, DK, Kirby, and Star Fox. All of the articles and retrospectives are written with a lot of passion and insight from dedicated Nintendo fans, and are a joy to read. The layouts and cover art are also spectacular! The Zelda issue pictured below was done by the talented Phil Summers, who created the Zelda Hand Drawn Game Guide, one of my favorite items in my collection.

Ninty Fresh Zelda Issue 4 Cover, surrounded by Zelda games
I’ll always have a soft spot for the Wii U Zelda releases.

You can still order all of their back issues in the online store! The fine folks at Ninty Media also ran another of the physical game magazines you should subscribe to…

Switch Player

July 2023 update: As of the Tears of the Kingdom issue (#69), Switch Player is no longer. I am leaving the original description below for posterity!

As far as I know, this is the only physical magazine that covers the Nintendo Switch! Why subscribe when you find Switch news all over the internet in a timely fashion? First, there are features from various contributors about all things Nintendo (I was lucky enough to write one about my nostalgia for the original N64 Mario Golf in Issue 53!). It’s a joy reading about what makes Nintendo games special to different folks, like the story about how Breath of the Wild helps manage anxiety in the issue pictured below. I appreciate that they get new voices in each issue!

Switch Player Issue 54 cover with Skyward Sword joy cons nearby
Skyward Sword has my favorite incarnation of Princess Zelda, and I absolutely love this cover art.

Second is the plethora of indie reviews every month! I always enjoy reading analyses of the “big titles”, but I’m a huge indie fan and really cherish how extensive and diverse their indie reviews are. There was a Cadence of Hyrule retrospective in the recent Zelda issue that was stellar! If you’re as a big a Switch nut as I am, this is definitely a physical game magazine you should subscribe to.

Retro Gamer

Retro Gamer is an institution in retro gaming mags. In fact, it was THE FIRST to cover retro gaming exclusively when it launched all the way back in 2004! I’m actually a recent subscriber, only a few issues in. And I’m blown away by the quality, depth, and breadth of each issue. More than any gaming magazine these days, I feel I genuinely learn A LOT about the hobby while reading Retro Gamer. There’s so much gaming history I missed since my gaming career started on the NES. And I’m filling in those gaps already! You never know what the next page of Retro Gamer will have, and for that, I love it. Insanely thorough, diverse, and run by a more than enthusiastic staff, it’s worth your time if you’re a retro gaming fan.

Retro Gamer Sonic Issue cover
This issue arrived just in time for my epic Sonic replays I was doing!

Game Informer

2024 update: Since PowerUp Rewards only includes a digital subscription, you can now purchase a separate print subscription here. I went with two years for a discounted rate!

Now I know GameStop takes a lot of heat for a variety of reasons, which I completely understand. But I have to say that their PowerUp Rewards is totally worth it for the Game Informer subscription alone! The “world’s biggest gaming mag” has been going strong for more than 300 issues for good reason. The editors are talented, the features are ludicrously deep, reviews are concise and fair, and the more recent “opinion” sections on gaming are very nuanced. I also appreciate how often they take the time to interview folks from all walks of the gaming industry. Plus, there’s a lot of humor, which I truly appreciate. Seeing the staff make fun of insane letters they receive is great, and the yearly April Fool’s section might be worth the price of a subscription alone. My preferred mag for more current all-around gaming news!

Game Informer Issue 300 Metroid Cover
I adore the cover of my Issue 300. Always great to see Metroid getting some love!

What are your picks for physical game magazines you should subscribe to? Do you enjoy leafing through magazines these days as much as me? Let me know in the comments below!

4 thoughts on “Physical Game Magazines You Should Subscribe To”

  1. I’ve been buying/subscribed to Retro Gamer since Darran took over editing in issue 18 or 19. Such a great magazine. You must be pretty happy with the recent DKC issue. 🙂

    I’d love to be able to afford Nintendo Force, Ninty Fresh and/or Switch Player as well.

    1. Oh wow that’s awesome that you’ve been on the Retro Gamer train for so long! (I’m a bit jealous) What a stellar publication that’s both so informative and laid out so pleasingly.

      And I hope you get the chance to subscribe to the other mags soon 🙂 I’d definitely nominate NF as the one you should pursue first, though I think shipping to Australia may be a bit costly. The digital subscription is also very reasonable!

  2. Looking for new posts is like that “new magazine in the mail” feeling.

    Thank you for mentioning EGM. I owe most of gaming cred, if such a thing exists, to that magazine. To me it stood out from “the rest” with its multi platform coverage, exclusive scoops and more mature tone. Mature for a gaming magazine at least.

    Impressive that you have physical Retro Gamer issues. I’m always tempted to buy their digital “90% off the entire catalog” deal they have. But then you couldn’t thumb through the magazine and sniff those wonderful print magazine chemicals (be honest we did and would kill for that).

    Come to think of it, what if the entire “forced physical” game movement is less about preserving digital games long past its initial console lifespan, and more about enjoying that “new game” smell? These the hard questions The Chozo Project conjures up with its excellent analysis and dare I say it may well answer as well.

    EGM forever!

    1. I’m seriously so happy I can at least contribute a bit to the nostalgic “new magazine in the mail” feeling :).

      The more mature theme of EGM definitely resonated back in its heyday. I wish I would’ve had an actual subscription, but I loved what I did read, and have really enjoyed combing through archives on the internet too!

      Retro Gamer definitely isn’t cheap to ship to the States but I just went for it since there was a deal and I’d always wanted to check it out. You are 100% spot on talking about the smell of print magazines-that’s the first thing I do after taking off the plastic, and my wife does the same since she appreciates it too :).

      You’re on to something with the physical game collecting being all about “new game smell”. It’s really a multi-sensory experience. You see the box art and labels on the shelf, smell the manuals, hear the click of the cart when games are placed in the console. Now that I’m typing this, I’m definitely adding it to the list of posts for the future!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.