The Best Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Games

Will the upcoming Shredder’s Revenge be one of the best Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles games? I certainly hope so, but in the meantime, let’s look at some excellent Turtles titles you can play right now! If you grew up in the late 80s and early 90s, you’re almost certainly familiar with the phenomena that was the Ninja Turtles. The mixture of a novelty concept, vibrant animation, fun characters, epic battles, and 90s attitude was near irresistible! The Turtles have evolved and endured into the present day in a variety of iterations, but I’ll always have a soft spot for the classics.

Turtles II NES cart, Turtles III NES cart, Hyperstone Heist Genesis cart, Turtles in Time SNES cart, and Fall of the Foot Clan GB cart all surrounded by early 90s Turtles action figures
Of course I had to bust out my old Turtles figures for this post.

This post may contain affiliate links

If you happen to be new to Turtle’s fandom, check out the original run of episodes on YouTube. (or pick them up dirt cheap if you’re a collector). The first five constitute a “mini-series” that introduces the lore and characters in all their glory, and they hold up remarkably well! (thanks to Kamal for the heads up about them). If you’re a longtime fan like me, here’s the ludicrously nostalgic/amazing opening for a quick trip down memory lane:

Like any licensed property, the Turtles games do vary in quality across the decades they’ve been released. There are some duds (or “bummers”, if you will) to be sure. Yet some of the Turtles games stand alongside the greatest beat ’em ups ever made! Let’s look at my personal top five best Ninja Turtles games, with a quick note on how you can play it today (spoiler: either purchase the phenomenal Cowabunga Collection or utilize these eBay tips). Cowabunga dude!

Vintage Ninja Turtles collector's case
I’ve had this case since I was only a few years old. When I got it out to take photos I was delighted to see my girls loved playing with all the old figures!

5. Fall of the Foot Clan (Game Boy, 1990)

I only just picked this one up a few months ago, and it quickly took at spot in my top 10 best Game Boy games too! Fall of the Foot Clan is a bit simple in retrospect-a straightforward sidescroller with little platforming and basic attacks. You pick a Turtle and make your way through stages of a few screens each while Foot Soldiers, mousers, and obstacles come at you relentlessly. It’s never very tough or all that original. But what it lacks in complexity it nails in the vibe of Ninja Turtles. The sprites look amazing, the music is spectacular for the Game Boy hardware, and the bosses in particular are a blast to fight. With only five stages, the game is over in an hour or so, but you’ll be smiling the whole way through! It’s the Turtles embodiment of “short but sweet”.

Turtles Fall of the Foot Clan Game Boy box, cart, and manual with Rocksteady and Bebop action figures
I strongly recommend picking up this manual too. The character bios are a thing of beauty!

Playing it today: You’ll need an original Game Boy cart and a way to play it (I recommend the Super Game Boy!). Luckily the game is very cheap and not too hard to find, especially cart only.

4. Turtles II: The Arcade Game (Arcade/NES, 1989)

This was THE Turtles game for quite some time! If you’re old enough to have gotten the opportunity, playing in the arcade was a glorious experience. The design of the Turtles and enemies were eye-popping at the time, and you could play with three other friends! Lengthy, challenging, gorgeous, and a celebration of both the animated show and comics- Turtles II had it all! The NES port is a bit more rough around the edges when revisiting today, but still shines as one of the best Ninja Turtles games, especially with played with a friend.

Turtles II Arcade Game NES cart, box, manual, and action figures of Leonardo, Donatello, Rafael, and Michaelangelo
It’s really hard to beat that box art.

And remember how much Pizza Hut sponsored the game? My manual still has the coupon for a free personal pan pizza!

Turtles II NES manual Pizza Hut coupon
What are the odds Pizza Hut will let me redeem this?

Playing it today: If you were lucky enough to download the arcade edition to XBox Live Arcade years ago, consider yourself lucky! That version has been de-listed for some time. Turtles Arcade1UP cabinets are available for pre-order very soon, but they’ll cost you a pretty penny. NES carts save the day since they’re dirt cheap-I bought mine at my local game store and cleaned it up to make it shine!

3. The Hyperstone Heist (Genesis, 1992)

If you’ve read other Chozo Project posts, you know I was a Genesis kid during the 16-bit era. And one of the games I was proud to own was Turtles Hyperstone Heist! It’s often looked down upon as a “lesser” version of Turtles in Time, but holds its own with some unique features despite sharing a lot in common. Levels are much longer and quite detailed, lasting several screens with changes in scenery, obstacles, and combat! Movement feels just a *bit* faster, and there’s a designated run button-much appreciated. Each Turtle has a special attack that takes off some life bars but is powerful and very effective when used at the right time. Boss encounters all play out differently, and the story forges its own path as well (Shredder shrinks Manhattan down to model size using some magical stones-how evil!). The soundtrack may not be quite as awesome as Turtles IV, but this is a great game that deserves a spot among the best Ninja Turtles games.

The 8bitdo 2.4g Genesis controller is the way to play Hyperstone Heist!

Playing it today: The only official release of this gem was the Sega Genesis cart, folks. Unfortunately due to rarity and Turtle mania, prices are very high, particularly for complete in box! I managed to find a deal on a box and cart sans manual, but hacking the Sega Mini or emulating might be the most practical move here.

2. Turtles III: The Manhattan Project (NES, 1992)

I can’t say this enough: this game deserves way, way more love. It’s often overlooked because it released on the NES just months before Turtles in Time (when most folks had moved on to the Super Nintendo). But the game is wonderful and a massive improvement over the Turtles II NES port in just about every way! Stages are a lot more vibrant, creative, and lengthy. The enemy AI is more balanced, and combat is more varied too. Each turtle has an added “flip enemy” move executed by holding down + attack to one-hit kill foot soldiers, but my favorite is the addition of “special moves” unique to each Turtle that take a life bar to execute and look awesome. When you’re down to one life bar, you get unlimited uses! (each play through will have “photo finishes” where you barely take down a boss with your special move before dying)

Turtles III Manahattan Project box, cart, manual with action figures for Slash, Shredder, Mouser, Tokka, and Foot Soldier
I loved that you fought “regular Shredder” in the Technodrome but it wasn’t the end of the game.

Additionally, with each life lost you can choose a new turtle to play, instead of waiting for a game over. I always appreciated the opportunity to switch up characters more frequently! Finally, the soundtrack also rocks hard-Scenes 4, 7, and 8 are personal favorites. All the “stage clear” sound bites are insanely catchy too. You need to experience this second best Ninja Turtles game!

Playing it today: Once more, a game that was never re-released (a shame for all humanity, really). You’re looking at emulation, hacking the NES classic, or an original NES cart. It’s not *too* bad if you’re going for cart only like I did. Check out my NES games worth playing post for some tips on how to make your NES look great on modern TVs!

1. Turtles in Time (Arcade/SNES, 1991/1992)

Was there any question? This is the game my friends and I play through every single time we do a “classic game day” together. It’s one I’ll just pop into my SNES and play for a few minutes when I need some instant joy. Everything about Turtles in Time works! The graphics are stunning to this day. The soundtrack is spectacularly catchy and 90s inspired. Time-traveling allows for a host of fun and silly settings. (I always love a good time-based story, even when it’s just kind of shoehorned in). Boss fights are not only numerous and challenging but full of fun cameos from across the Turtles lore. And the beat ’em up mechanics just feel right. I mean, how satisfying is it to throw enemies into the screen? (answer: insanely satisfying). Even the title names for each stage are so quintessential 90s, and classic Turtles. It’s all so ludicrously nostalgic and comforting.

Turtles in Time SNES box, cart, 8bitdo SNES controller, and action figures for Leonardo, Donatello, Raphael, and Michaelangelo
One of my favorite levels is “Neon Night Riders” where the Turtles glide through a futuristic city on hoverboards to a glorious soundtrack. If the only the real 2020 A.D. had been that awesome!

An absolute must play for any Turtles or beat ’em up fans (or just fans of video games, let’s be honest), Turtles in Time is THE BEST Ninja Turtles game ever made.

Playing it today: There are a few options here, but it’s still not easy! The SNES cart is now fairly pricey, but isn’t completely out of hand considering the quality of the game. The Arcade 1UP has the game if you really want to get serious, as does Turtles III: Mutant Nightmare for the PS2, GameCube, and XBox (as an unlockable early on). Just avoid the “Re-Shelled” release for XBLA!

Have you been a longtime TMNT fan, or are you a recent convert? What do you think the best Ninja Turtles games are? Let me know in the comments below!

8 thoughts on “The Best Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Games”

  1. You must be on cloud 9 now that Shredder’s Revenge and the Cowabunga Collection have released. 🙂 I’m looking forward to picking up the collection to revisit the original NES TMNT – I enjoyed it back in the day but never got past some of the trickier jumps in the airport level.

    Also, interesting to see that Konami published a couple of these using their secondary brand, Ultra. I know they set that up to get around Nintendo’s limit of 5 releases per year per publisher, but I’m surprised TMNT 2 didn’t make it out under their main brand!

    1. Oh my gosh yes, this has been a glorious year to be a Turtles fan! Some of my oldest friends and I have had an absolute blast playing Shredder’s Revenge together-it feels like we’re back in the 90s, and it’s been even more fun introducing our kids to it and playing with them as well 🙂 I’ve been able to finish Radical Rescue on the Cowabunga Collection (I never got to play that one-it’s a really solid title but the boss fights are ludicrously hard!) but I haven’t gone back to the original game yet-it’s also in my backlog to finish at some point.

      And cool trivia about the “Ultra” publishing-I never knew that!

  2. Ah yes thanks for correcting Radical Rescue vs Rescuepalooza. I haven’t played either… definitely something to try out time permitting.

    Glad you got Back from the Sewers! Interested to see what fresh, non kid eyes of it. Playing first with Fall of the Foot Clan will be great context for how far the Turtles GameBoy titles had come…

      1. Ah so fun fact: Resue-Palooza is based on the OpenBOR (Beats of Rage) engine which has spawned numerous beat ‘em ups over the years. I still want to try the original Beats of Rage series on the Dreamcast. Life goals.

        1. Zach Lindemann

          So cool! I had no idea. Maybe someday when our kids are older can take an entire weekend and just binge a bunch of excellent beat ’em ups. They’d play with us!!

  3. I feel like I’ve been waiting my whole life for this Turtles post!

    Thank you for advising against “Turtles in Time Reshelled” – one of the worst and most disappointing remakes likely ever in gaming.

    Ok back to the good: I really need to go back and really play through the Manhattan Project. I also want to track down Radical Rescue (fan made hack) which is supposed to also be of quality.

    Honorable mentions:
    – Turtles II: Back from the Sewers on GameBoy
    – Tournament Fighters: This is a Street Fighter II clone that was fairly decent for its time. I had fun with it. Would I buy it on a cart given current prices and “Turtle Mania” as Zach puts it? I would not.

    The original Xbox is also an emulation goldmine if you want to go that route. Personally I’d try to get a mini version of the NES, SNES or build a Raspberry Pi for cheap and get the usb version of the controllers for each system. Especially if you’re just curious about the game.

    Zach that Action Figure holder you have is amazing. I think I remember seeing that as a young lad way back when. Very nice!

    I always considered Hyperstone Heist “lesser” than Turtles in Time but I was biased and naive in the 16-days and just went on popular opinion (who had money to afford both systems and both games?). I finally played through HH this January and can say it is on par with its SNES counterpart and better in some ways (speed, difficulty). Just want to put it out there!

    Turtles II: The Arcade Game coming home to the NES was a _very_ big deal. You finally had co-op turtles action at home. And the game was actually fun, unlike the single player only and brutal Turtles I game on NES. And yes smashing through a brick wall on skateboards is so full of 90’s ‘tude that it demands your attention. Love it.

    Turtle Power!

    1. Zach Lindemann

      Turtle Power ALWAYS! Thanks for all the positive feedback :). I remember that action figure case came with a tray that only held twelve figures, so it wasn’t long before I just tossed it out since I had so many! It’s still overflowing with way too many versions of the same characters (why do I have a “Beach Donatello” that spits water?)

      I just recently picked up a cart of Back to the Sewers for Game Boy but haven’t really tried it out yet! And I think Radical Rescue is the elusive third Game Boy game with a few Metroidvania-ish elements (that’s super expensive now), and Rescue-Palooza is the fan game? Regardless, I’ve heard great things about both! I remember very briefly trying out Tournament Fighters on the Genesis and not being too impressed, but I’m also terrible at fighting games and don’t think I gave it a fair shake. I’ll have to check out some gameplay videos and give it another chance!

      Excellent advice on how to play all the games on one console. Between Konami generally being difficult and the trickiness of rights to the Turtles IP, it’s certainly not easy. Maybe if Shredder’s Revenge is really successful everything will come together and we’ll get a sweet collection at some point! A man can dream.

      And spot on analysis of Hyperstone Heist. It’s very slick to control and in some ways absolutely feels better than Turtles IV! It deserves more love 🙂

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.